Butternut squash, kale, pumpkin seed pesto
Bacon, spinach, tomato, classic sauce
Truffled mushrooms, peas, asiago, parmesan, bechamel sauce
Chipotle chicken, roasted corn, blistered tomato, classic sauce
Includes bottled water & a piece of whole fruit
From a reviewer’s perspective, the menu at Cafe 57 delivers a blend of casual comfort and customizable options that stand out on West 57th Street. The Mac & Cheese offerings include creative varieties such as “Farmers Market” and the more indulgent “Truffle Tex‑Mex,” which showcase seasonal and rich flavor profiles. The Deli Menu lets diners “Build Your Own” sandwich to suit individual tastes or opt for the “Daily Special” that’s attractively priced at $6.25, striking a balance between quality and value. For those seeking a straightforward meal deal, the “Value Meal” - complete with bottled water and whole fruit - comes in at just $9.25, making it ideal for a quick, satisfying lunch without breaking the bank. Overall, the menu does a solid job of combining familiar favorites with flexible choices that appeal whether you drop in for a fast bite or a relaxed midday meal.